|
The man convicted of murdering Brighton schoolteacher Jane
Longhurst has lost his appeal against conviction but won a reduction in his
sentence.
Graham Coutts, 36, of Waterloo Street, Hove, Sussex, but
originally from Fife, was jailed for life last year.
At the appeal in December, his defence team argued a verdict of
manslaughter should have been offered at the trial.
On Friday three judges at London's Court of Appeal said his
30-year minimum jail term should be cut to 26.
'Accident during sex'
Lord Woolf, the Lord Chief Justice, sitting with Mr Justice
Creswell and Mr Justice Simon, ruled Coutts' murder conviction was safe.
However, the court said his case raised issues of "general public
importance" fit for consideration by the House of Lords.
Jane, a special needs teacher, was strangled with a pair of
tights in March 2003.
Coutts kept her body in a storage unit for weeks before it was
found badly burned on Wiggonholt Common in West Sussex.
At his trial in February last year, he admitted he had been with
her when she died, but always denied murder, saying her death was an accident
during consensual sex.
The claim it was wrong for the jury not to have been offered an
alternative verdict of manslaughter, one of the reasons Coutts' legal team gave
as grounds for his conviction being overturned, was opposed by the Crown.
John Kelsy-Fry, on behalf of the Crown, told the appeal court the
case was presented as an "uncluttered" contest between murder and accident.
If the case had failed on this basis the defendant would deserved
to be acquitted, he said.
'Justice done'
When Coutts was found guilty in his trial at Lewes Crown Court,
he was given a life sentence with a recommended minimum term of 30 years.
Jane, who was 31 when she was killed, was originally from
Reading, Berkshire.
Commenting on the court's decision to throw out the conviction
appeal, Jane's mother Liz said: "I am very relieved it has gone the way it has.
"I am delighted. I feel that justice has been done and has
been seen to be done."
|